Hi 100rabbits,
There are two: Quick Drying Medium Matte/Gloss Paste. I've used both, but like you, I found the Gloss too shiny. I tried the Matt for impasto work and I also had a hard time working with it. It's not thick enough for impasto and it becomes tacky too quickly. I wish they had little trial tubes in these things so that we don't have to waste our money!
I don't have anything else to tell you 100...sorry.
Linnette